Ethan Zuckerman’s online home, since 2003

One Laptop Per Child – a preview, and a request for help

I took a day off from this year’s Pop!Tech conference to hang out with some friends in Portland. But before driving from Camden to Portland, I dropped into the Opera House to check email and bumped into Nicholas Negroponte, who’d given a talk the day before on his work to produce a laptop that costs less than a hundred dollars.

Negroponte was an advisor to Geekcorps and was extremely helpful to me as we figured out whether the organization would be supported by corporate sponsorship, foundations or government largesse. So he knows about my long-standing interest in technology in the developing world. He asked whether I was interested in coming over to the lab and seeing a demo of the machine, and talking about strategies for deployment.

Hell yeah.

The demo was yesterday afternoon, and while it didn’t include a functioning prototype, I learned a great deal more about machine than I have from previous articles, or Negroponte’s talk at Pop!Tech. He was able to answer a whole set of questions for me, and raise an entire set of new ones, which, I suspect, will take a number of years to answer accurately.

First, the name. I’d been calling the project the sub-hundred dollar laptop… the acronym of which is the unfortunate “SHiL”. Negroponte’s now calling the project OLPC – One Laptop Per Child. It does a better job of defining the project, I think – not taking the bottom out of the consumer laptop market, but providing a learning tool for students around the world.

On to the machine. While the actual prototype is being actively banged on (in preparation for a live, but tethered, demo at WSIS on November 16th), Negroponte keeps a cardboard mockup of the machine on the conference table in his office. It’s a clever little thing – I had a hard time putting it down after picking it up. You can see a design close to the prototype I saw on the front page of Design Continuum’s site – they’re evidently doing the case design for the machine… and, actually, pretty far from the design reported on in the AP story about the project.

The mockup I saw was about the size of a large paperback book. There’s a stiff rubber gasket around the edge of the machine, which can double as a stand. The keyboard on the mockup was detachable, but will probably fold out on a hinge. The system is designed to work in three modes: laptop mode (screen up, keyboard down, handle behind as a stand); book mode (screen on the front, keyboard on the back, comfortable indentation for holding it in the left hand. Pressing on the keyboard “accordian-stype” – as Negroponte puts it – allows for page scrolling); and game mode (screen in the front, keyboard in the back, held sideways, like an oversized PSP. Two trackballs, surrounded by four way buttons, on each side of the screen act as controls, and function keys on the back act as additional buttons.)

Unlike in the prototype featured in the AP story, there’s no large gap between the screen and battery section, designed as a handle. While it looked very cool, it was also a bit too fragile for the conditions being considered. The handle now is either the rubber gasket or the indentation in the back. I wonder if the hinges are going to be a problem – the current design requires a hinge for the gasket and a separate hinge that allows 340 degrees of freedom between the screen and the keyboard. Negroponte pointed out to me that the hinges in the average consumer laptop cost about $5 each, and have a complex clutch mechanism that allows a screen to be smoothly rotated and repositioned – it will be interesting to see what can be done on a machine where the hinges will need to cost pennies, not dollars.

The keyboard on the prototype I saw was removeable – I think this was a nod to the idea that separate keyboards will need to be produced for different markets. In China, the appropriate device might be a stylus and pad rather than a keyboard, making it easier to enter ideograms.

Much of the conversation about the laptop has centered on the display, one of the most expensive components of a modern laptop. Early designs called for an e-Ink display – while Negroponte keeps a large e-Ink display on his conference table (about twice the size of the one in the Sony Librié), he tells me that eInk is for the second generation of the device. (It’s easy to see why e-Ink is compelling. Not only is the display extremely crisp in black and white, it remains crisp and readable when the display is turned off, as the molecules that make up the letters retain their orientation despite the absence of current. This makes power requirements for texts that don’t change continuously very, very low.)

Instead, the first generation of devices will use an LCD screen, though one rather different from the ones in most consumer laptops. The screen I’m staring at as I type this is backlit with white light – it’s what’s called a transmissive display. To produce colors on the screen, there are three colored filters that can be selectively applied to each pixel – these filters allow each pixel to display a huge range of colors. But these filters block a huge amount of the light a display transmits, up to 85%, which make displays extremely power-hungry.

There are other strategies for producing color from a transmissive display – one can create the illusion of colored pixels by flashing red, green and blue pixels in sequence – unfortunately, LCD displays don’t refresh quickly enough to make this technique workable. So Negroponte is using a display that puts red, green and blue pixels near each other, blurring into a single, colored pixel. The monitor will have three colored backlights, and each pixel on the monitor will have three small lenses, etched into a lenticular screen – each lens will pick up only one of the three backlights. The screen will also be able to work in a black and white, reflective mode, useful when the laptop is being used in bright light or sunlight.

While the display is going to need to be custom manufactured, Negroponte believes it will be possible to produce it at a fraction of the cost of traditional displays, and his team is already negotiating with display manufacturers in Asia to produce the product. It’s likely to be significantly less sharp than the LCD displays we’re used to, but will use far less power. Negroponte’s goal is for the machine to work on a 100:1 crank ratio – one minute of hand cranking generates sufficient power for the laptop to operate for 100 minutes.

I had several dozen questions based on my work with computers in challenging environments, and Negroponte had excellent answers to almost all of them. 12 volt power? There’s an adaptor for that. Voltage surges? Shouldn’t be a major problem given the most power draw of the machine. Cooling? The machine doesn’t have a fan since the processor is fairly slow and there’s no disk drive. The one hardware area where I wasn’t entirely satisfied with the answers had to do with mesh wireless support – some work in mesh suggests that it’s useful to have two radios per machine to provide robust backbones for sharing connectivity, and the current machine has only one radio, likely as a cost concession.

I didn’t get to see the software being designed to operate the machine, but learned a bit more about the team working on it. A small team of Red Hat engineers are customizing a Red Hat distro to the processor and hardware specifications of the machine. They’re doing some work on the GUI as well, as are Alan Kay and Seymour Papert – the total development team is about 18 people, including Kay’s students at the media lab. The machine will come with tools to encourage students to experiment with programming, including Squeak (a graphical environment for the Smalltalk programming language) and Logo. The plan is to make the software available online in a few months so that testers can bang on it and suggest features.

Localizing the software for different languages, learning styles and environments is going to require local production of software, which Negroponte appears to be planning for. Production of the hardware locally, on the other hand, is going to be “optional”… by which he seems to mean, “Some countries are going to insist on producing this lately, but it will be near impossible for them to do so at quantities that make it affordable.” Scale is clearly a major part of what will make the laptop succeed or fail – the laptop won’t be produced unless at least five countries sign up at a million laptops each. With an initial production run of 5 to 10 million laptops, the price is likely to be between $130 and $150 per unit, not including any distribution costs, marketing, or any digital content that comes pre-installed on the box. As the project scales up, the $100 per box target comes into sight.

The laptop is not “for sale” – it’s going to be available for students only, and will be distributed through the same channels that school books and uniforms are. The laptops will be the property of children, not of the school. Colin Maclay, a Berkman colleague who’d joined me for the visit, pointed out that in many countries, school books and uniforms are sold by (highly profitable) local businesses, and that losing a book contract might be a major blow for local employers. Negroponte points out that this doesn’t have to be a revenue loss – publishers could sell the electronic rights to textbooks on a per copy basis, which might make electronic textbooks even more attractive, on a revenue basis, than paper ones.

This might complicate the economics of the device. The idea is to make the laptop required equipment for all school students and price it on a basis where it replaces textbooks. In some of the developing world school systems Negroponte has investigated, textbooks cost $20 per student per year – if the laptop is sold to students (or provided by the national government) with a five-year financing option, it costs the same amount as annual textbook spending. Except that, if schools need to license intellectual property from existing publishers, the cost would certainly increase.

Talking through the structure of the OLPC initiative, Negroponte mentions that he was having a tough time figuring out who could be the CEO of the entire project. “In the startup phase, we need someone who’s halfway between Michael Dell and some great supply-chain genius. But in three years, we’re going to need someone halfway between Kofi Annan and Seymour Papert.”

The solution – run three separate groups: OLPC hardware (possibly based in Silicon Valley or Asia), OLPC software (likely based at the Media Lab) and OLPC International (based in New York, Geneva or another global hub.) It’s this third unit – the one charged with distributing, localizing and supporting the machines, and figuring out how they get used in global schools – that I’m most fascinated by.

While Negroponte has some general solutions to the interesting problems around distribution and usage, I got the sense that there hasn’t been as much detailed thinking about the on-the-ground challenges as there has been about the physical and software design of the machine. Colin wanted to know how Negroponte was navigating the complex internecene politics of working with the various ministries of a government – is this project owned by the Ministry of Education or the Ministry of Information and Communications. Negroponte explained that he was just working with heads of state, counting on them to get their teams to implement the project. Colin and I exchanged glances – we’d both worked with President Leonel Fernández of the Dominican Republic, a visionary leader who’d dedicated himself to bringing technology to the DR in 1996. His party was voted out of power in 2000 by a kleptocrat who ran on a platform of “Plantains, not PCs”, and pro-IT reforms were rolled back. (Fernandez is back in office now, after last year’s elections.) I’m guessing that a OLPC project started under one leader could stall under a future leader.

My questions largely had to do with how the laptop would be used in the classroom. I made the mistake of asking a question of how the laptop would be used as “a teaching tool”… like Papert, Negroponte’s a big believer that students simply need access to technology and can use it to teach each other and to make discoveries themselves. When I expressed some skepticism about teachers’ willingness to use the computers in the classroom, he referenced Maine governor Angus King’s initiative to bring computers into middle school classrooms throughout the state. Initially unpopular with teachers, the laptop project is now widely viewed as a success and is being replicated in other states. It’s clear that the strategy behind the device is a trojan horse one – sell the device as an e-book, then see what students are able to do with a flexible, net-connected, programmable tool.

After peppering Negroponte with two hours of questions, I’m fairly convinced that this laptop won’t suffer the problems the Simputer did – I believe it will get produced and distributed and that the software will enable e-books, web browsing, word processing and programming. As much as I enjoy the geekery of challenging Negroponte and others on the fine points of hardware and software design for the developing world, I’m convinced that some extremely smart people are working very hard on the hardware and software side of things. While I might question some of the decisions made, I don’t know that my second-guessing is helpful at this point.

On the third and fourth fronts of the project – the marketing, distribution and maintenance of these devices and their connection to the Internet, and their use in the classroom – I think there’s a lot of unanswered questions and I think the global community of folks interested in IT in education, especially in IT in the developing world, could assist Negroponte and team with their thinking.

Specifically, I think it would be great for the OLPC team to have a set of requirements and suggestions for nations participating in the program on how to distribute, link, support and teach with the laptops. It sounds like Negroponte would like to make it a requirement that every student in a classroom has a laptop. Should it be a requirement that schools implementing laptops have internet connectivity? Can this connectivity be used the way it is in the SchoolNet Namibia project, to let schools become ISPs, using revenue to subsidize the net connection and, perhaps, the laptops? Will businesses repair the laptops? Or will students do it informally, or start their own businesses?

Colin and I are talking about soliciting suggestions on the distribution and use questions surrounding the One Laptop Per Child project and compiling them into an advisory paper for Negroponte and crew. (If you’ve got questions or suggestions, posting them on this blog is a great way to start a discussion…)

One Laptop Per Child is an amazingly ambitious and radical project. If it succeeds, it will radically change how the world learns, communicates and interacts over the next couple of decades. And if it fails, it will likely scare off anyone from trying anything this radical in technology and education for many years to come. For that reason alone, I’d like to make sure it doesn’t fail, and would love your help in figuring out ways to make sure it succeeds.

27 Responses to “One Laptop Per Child – a preview, and a request for help”

  1. Ethan, have you read Todd Oppenheimer’s “The Flickering Mind”?

  2. Ethan says:

    Nope. And based on the description of it I just read, I’m guessing NN hasn’t either… :-)

  3. Justin Mason says:

    I posted my thoughts over on Slashdot at http://linux.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=167342&cid=13952519 — I’ll paste ‘em here too:

    ‘The $100 price point for this device is based on unrealistic volume assumptions, in my opinion — Ethan notes that it’ll likely start off at $130 to $150 ‘not including any distribution costs, marketing, or any digital content that comes pre-installed on the box’ assuming 5 countries sign up for a million laptops each.

    IMO those are pretty optimistic prices. Having worked on a low-cost laptop-like device in the past, in our experience we found that the normal fluctuations of the component market can cause the price point to swing wildly.

    Having said that, I wish them luck! Being Irish, I can tell you that adoption of high tech really can bring major benefits to a society…’

  4. Ethan says:

    I’d be tempted to agree with you, had I not spent two hours talking with Negroponte, who was able to quote with a high degree of specificity the costs of individual components. It will be interesting to see whether, with orders in the tens of millions, Negroponte is able to affect market prices, or whether they affect him instead… :-)

  5. N says:

    Hey Ethan,
    Great post! As for the keyboard that will be used in China, it will interest you to know that the only Chinese who use a stylus to write characters are middle/old aged. Every young user I know uses one of many input methods that rely on the standard pc keyboard. This would be true regardless of whether they knew English, as most keyboards in Greater China have 2-3 different character components or phonetic symbols in addition to English letters.

  6. N says:

    Sorry. that’s 2-3 phonetic symbols in addition to the English letter on every key.

  7. Ruud says:

    What the hell…
    Every child a laptop… To what purpose?
    So they van check their migration plan when they are on the run?
    Or see a Perrier commercial when the are in need of water?

    WHY!

  8. Mr Alex Weir says:

    Without Content, the project is greatly diminished. And Connectivity is often non-existent, slow, and relatvely expensive. Offline content is the solution. Check out my CD3WD project which has 662 megabytes of downloadable offline content on agriculture, technology, health, watsan etc etc and is very suitable for the OLPC Project.

    Alex Weir, Geekcorps Volunteer.

  9. arjun says:

    wher can i find a free laptop.am a student and i need a laptop plzzz

  10. lakmal says:

    I’m a master’s student. I need laptop for my research. Where can i find free laptop for my research.

  11. kalpesh says:

    can i have one of ur laptops free as i need it ..

  12. Jessica says:

    Im a single parent trying to pursue a degree in nursing. I need to find out how i can get an free laptop

  13. alicia says:

    i am a single parent that just lost my job, due to the factory moving to mexico. i am in school and a need a laptop and am unsable to buy one. Can anybody help me on finding a organization out there i can get help at?

  14. cheap laptop says:

    Me Again,this need for cheap computers has me thinking,I from time to time have repaired old desktop computers and given them to people in my local area for free or for very low cost, if people all over the world started doing this on a local scale the amount of people needing pc’s to improve education options for children and adults alike would surely be reduced.Just THINK WHAT YOU HAVE DO YOU KNOW SOME FAMILY IN NEED?.
    “OUT OF LITTLE THINGS BIG THINGS GROW”

  15. While the hardware will be a challenge, I thing that the open software environment is the only chance the project will have because ubuntu and open office for free provides the majority of the functionality needed by an average student. I think if the students can use wireless at school, they could download each day what they need for their lessons. Internet at hoome will come much later. The whole idea is inspiring.

  16. Joey says:

    “Colin and I are talking about soliciting suggestions on the distribution and use questions surrounding the One Laptop Per Child project and compiling them into an advisory paper for Negroponte and crew.”

    I am working on a similar idea. I am at present in Buenos Aires. I am compiling a list, see end of this post, to invite to a “Bar Camp” style meeting. That is, all those invited will be given the option to present.

    What and why?

    Negroponte has been clear that a major reason for the price of the laptop is the lack of sales and marketing expenses.

    My aim with the meeting is to create recognition of the fact that we (read for “we” anyone who has an interest in the project whether for or against), and most immediately the people of Argentina, are the sales, marketing, promotion and research team.

    Negroponte has also mentioned the attempts to get the various governments looking at purchasing the laptops to co-operate. He says that it hasn’t been easy. What if it were the educational associations and teachers of these countries that they were trying to get to communicate with each other in preparation for the arrival of the laptops? What if they were in touch with Maine? How about establishing a network and means of communication for the interested parties within these counties? If the networks are established before the arrival of the laptops then they will be ready to share and help each other after……

    It is my belief that if realised and successfully implemented, this is a project of historic proportions. As far as I am aware the arrival of one million laptops (and certainly if say 4 countries go live with 4 million) will represent not only the largest ever human network created in one go but the largest single distribution of the same tool. The only other example I can think of being the issuing of weapons. What a difference: as the pen is mightier than the sword so the laptop may prove to be mightier than the AK47.

    If launched in 2008 to 4 year olds in Argentina, a group of students who had spent their entire educational lives networked on open source laptops as their key educational tool would emerge from the system around 2020-2022. What are the likely results?

    The agenda for the meeting I am proposing would be to discuss media coverage, promote debate, ask those present who they think should get the laptops, how they think they could/should be used…….

    It terms of feeding back to the people I hope to find out if anyone is willing to produce a documentary on the project and it’s imminent arrival in Argentina. I figure TV to be the most effective medium for reaching the population who it seems know very little about it. Interviews with parents, kids, teachers and many from the invite list below could be a good start…..

    So who do I plan to invite to this meeting?

    The producers of the most respected TV documentaries in Argentina

    The producers of the most respected documentaries in the world

    Appropriate professors from Buenos Aires University: departments of education, technology and social sciences.

    The editors of the main newspapers and selected magazines in Argentina

    The head of strategy for Google’s new ventures in Argentina

    The founders of Google

    The appropriate members of the Argentine Government’s department of Technology and Science.

    Every blogger in Argentina that has shown great interest in the project

    Last and certainly not least:

    Members of key educational associations, teachers and appropriate members of the Department of Education

    …..and a group of school kids.

    I would ideally love to have Nicholas Negroponte be there too. He says that he visits Argentina every 3 months. I have the mails of a good few of the OLPC team and will be suggesting as much to them.

    I have pretty much completed the e-mailing list. I should be ready to send it within the next few days. I would be very interested to hear your thoughts before I do.

  17. Evadney says:

    I’m living in a little country in South America named Guyana. I saw your story on Sixty Minutes. Dont give up on your dream! Every big idea starts with a dream…Dont be discouraged because of Intel…You have made a difference in so many children’s life, so stand firm and continue the great work.

  18. Evadney says:

    Maybe you can visit Guyana sometime. We are nowhere near the surface of the poverty line. Our young people need help. I love the way you are empowering people all over the world…hats off to you!

  19. benali Mohammed el amine says:

    i’m a student in algeria and i can’t buy a computer because i’m very poor, if someone can help me and give me an old computer (even a pentium 1) i will be very gratful
    my adress is:

    cite 39 logements, batiment 01 Numero 03, Naama 45000 Algeria

  20. tolulope says:

    dear sir
    we are company base in nigeria and we are intrested in the bulk purchase of your child laptop base on the high demand for it my country and also we which to expand your business in ur region so need you to give us your best possible price.thanks
    ayodeji ogungbayibi
    salco limited

  21. sofia says:

    [....]well there are lots of way to buy and send cheap computer to poor students.One of the way i know is.
    http://www.electrocomputerwarehouse.com
    [...]

  22. Star says:

    I think all in all, the idea isnt too bad, but basically, i think we should be able to choose whom we want to donate to!!! If it is OUR money, there are LOTS of needy children in this world and we should be able to donate to 2 of the needy children WE choose!

    Star!

  23. tolu abraham adekomaiya says:

    i need a laptop for my studies.phone no (redacted), address 11,akewukewe street ijeshatedo surulere lagos state nigeria

  24. amoako richard says:

    I am a student of a university in ghana .I was brought up by my mother alone and I need a laptop for my studies since my mother can not afford it.I am looking a help.email address is (amoakorichard41@yahoo.com)

  25. I agree with Star. we should be able to choose whom we want to donate to.

  26. iam a single mom who been wanting to go school now that im can i dont have the money so i would love to have a new laptop

  27. ericson says:

    I have heard this project before many years back. This idea is very good and I wish to help some children.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Savage Minds: Notes and Queries in Anthropology — A Group Blog » Communication Technologies Old and New - [...] I suppose the digital divide seems so much more significant because expensive machines are required to connect to the …
  2. mtl3p - $100 laptop and "a young lady's illustrated primer" yes - i know that I've got neale stephenson permenantly on the brain. …
  3. …My heart’s in Accra » It’s cute. It’s orange. It’s got bunny ears - an update on the One Laptop Per Child project - [...] One of the most interesting phenomena surrounding the One Laptop Per Child project has been the amount of attention …
  4. EDITing in the Dark » More on the $100 laptop - [...] Edit - More here eSchool News, and here Etahn Zuckerman. Do the Social Bookmark thing:Social bookmark links [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

 

Powered by WordPress | Designed by Elegant Themes