Ethan Zuckerman’s online home, since 2003

Watching Bahrain through a friend’s eyes, heartbroken

Like anyone else trying to keep track of the revolutions in Egypt and Tunisia, the protests in Libya, Bahrain, Iran, Yemen and elsewhere, a pivotal election in Uganda, the ongoing collapse of the Ivory Coast, I’m feeling a little behind, a little lost, a little overwhelmed. In 2011, history has apparently accelerated – it feels like a decade’s events are happening in a few weeks. I’m watching friends write books in weeks – Micah Sifry on Wikileaks, my friends at Foreign Policy on the revolutions in the Middle East – rather than the years these works usually require. It’s the opposite of the end of history – everything is happening so fast that it’s hard to stop to reflect without missing the next chapter.

I’ve been trying to watch the protests in Yemen, Libya, Iran and Bahrain – as well as the stalled or subjugated protests in Gabon – with equal intensity, but I’m finding myself watching Bahrain most closely, for simple personal reasons: my dear friend Amira Al-Hussaini is there, and I’m increasingly watching these revolutions through her eyes. Amira is Middle East and North Africa editor for Global Voices, and is a fellow board member. I think it’s safe to say that there’s not a single person involved with our project who isn’t madly in love with her – she’s the den mother and fierce taskmaster for our amazing Middle East team, and she’s shattered countless stereotypes I’ve had about the Gulf, about women in the Arab world, about bloggers and journalists.

As protests began to erupt in Bahrain, Amira wrote a powerful blog post about her mixed emotions. She made it clear that, while she’s not a fan of the government in her country, she was unconvinced that protests would be the answer – she worried about sectarian strife in a country where a Sunni government and Shia majority have been in tension for years. Today, on Twitter, her reactions have been more raw and emotional:

I feel I have died over and over again since #Feb14 #Bahrain

@nour_odeh Is this how you feel covering the carnage in Palestine? Cried covering Tunisia and Egypt but this is real + here

@marwarakha Wanted celebrate in Tahrir with you guys so much – and look where I am. The same thing is happening in my country

Later today, she’s been responding to criticism from some fellow Bahrainis that her coverage of the atrocities committed by the Bahraini military against protesters is a betrayal of her identity as a Bahrani citizen. Needless to say, that’s not how she sees it:

As much as I understand why friends are making up excuses, the horror I’ve witnessed in my country cannot be excused #Feb14 #Bahrain

I too love #Bahrain. I am Bahraini. My blood is Bahraini – and I witnessed my country die in the eyes of its children today #Bahrain #Feb14

I have given up trying to understand. Nothing can explain it. Ppl can live in denial all they want. What happened is wrong #Bahrain #Feb14

Tweeting the atrocities committed is not treason: Keeping quiet about them is and hiding the truth is another low altogether #Bahrain #Feb14

Me tweeting falls within my line of work: I work in citizen media: I am the Middle East and North Africa of @globalvoices #Bahrain #Feb14

I have tweeted #bouzid and #Jan25 and cover #Yemen #Libya #Algeria and the rest of Middle East #Bahrain #Feb14

Covering protests/revolutions thru citizen media reactions means that u need to understand the scene: I started in 2004 #Bahrain #Feb14

Before that I was the news editor of the Gulf Daily News, where I worked for 14 years. I covered everything: everything #Feb14 #Bahrain

I served #Bahrain in every way I knew, never asked for anything. Today I ask it to stop the bloodshed and give us an explanation we can stomach

I am tired, shattered and broken. I saw ppls brain’s splattered and men in uniform shooting boys: Why? #Bahrain #Feb14

Amira has been sending me videos that Bahrani protesters are taking with their phones and posting to YouTube. She’s asked me to archive and mirror them – the young men taking the videos are deleting them after uploading for fear of being stopped at checkpoints, and everyone is afraid that YouTube will remove the videos as they are violent and very disturbing. For now, I’m embedding YouTube’s player – if they go down, I will post the originals on my server.

This first video makes clear that the Bahrani forces are firing live rounds from semiautomatic weapons.

The second video shows how close the tanks – and presumably, the gunmen – are to the protesters, who are peaceful and unarmed.

It’s hard to imagine how Bahrain returns to normal after innocent people are killed so brutally. Amira’s tweets gives me a sense for how disturbing it is to see a country you know and love go off the rails so tragically. I’m shocked as a human being by the videos. I’m disgusted as an American that we’ve not been able to stay the hand of our close ally. I’m sad that I’m not able to pay as close attention to Libya, where dozens are dying at the hands of government forces and out of the view of news cameras. As filled with hope as events in Tunisia and Egypt have left me, these videos leave me crushed.

5 Responses to “Watching Bahrain through a friend’s eyes, heartbroken”

  1. Miranda says:

    Thank you. I’ve been using Twitter to follow events, though I had always thought Twitter stupid. And I started reading Amira’s blog and following her tweets. I don’t know how to describe how I felt, seeing what happened the other night in Bahrain through Amira’s and others tweets.
    I had suggested last Sunday to a history teacher at the school where I work that her students follow Twitter for news on the middle east. I told her that students could get to know protestors as individuals through their blogs, their photos. Now I think that was a mistake.Because I feel shattered, I feel shattered. It is too immediate seeing events clearly, not through the gentler scrim of news reports.It is too close when you feel that it is happening to people you feel you know.
    Amira has cats and I have cats, that’s a stupid thing to make me feel close to her but it does.

  2. Chris says:

    Miranda, that’s a _beautiful_ thing to make you feel close to someone.

  3. gregorylent says:

    “history” IS “speeding up” … big paradigm shift has begun. it is irreversible. gathering speed the rest of the year, and into the decade. all mystics know this.

  4. LOrion says:

    I found from @monaeltahawy ‘s RT. and am sending it on. I found and have been following @justamira for days….
    Yes, Miranda I too think the cats are important. It is a rapid sharing of knowledge to know another person is a CAT person.
    The time is so far off I miss a lot of occurences there. Thanks for the review of her whole thread today. Ethan
    We all hope and pray some good can come of this confusion and carnage.
    I will say that as a physician I am appalled that the US Navy’s doctors haven’t responded to you… orders or not. There are good order and bad orders and you don’t follow BAD ones!

  5. Peregrine says:

    Dear Amira, our hearts beat with yours, your sadness is ours. I too am devastated by what has happened in Bahrain.Somehow thru your eyes, your blog, other tweets and YouTube videos, we have become so connected to the good innocent people of your country. My prayers go out to the families of those killed and wounded. Stay safe Amira. We need your voice and eyes. What is happening in Bahrain, and other countries of the Middle East is impacting the hearts and minds of people across the world. Take care Amira, take care.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Tweets that mention …My heart’s in Accra » Watching Bahrain through a friend’s eyes, heartbroken -- Topsy.com - [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Ethan Zuckerman, Asteris Masouras, Onnik Krikorian, cbgreenwood, Robert Guerra and others. Robert …
  2. …My heart’s in Accra » How restless a searchlight?: Using Media Cloud to measure the change in media cycles - [...] sharply than at other points in our study – to be somewhat reassuring. About six weeks ago, I offered …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

 
Powered by WordPress | Designed by Elegant Themes